Sheng Li (gmachine1729) wrote,
Sheng Li

Some speculations on the positive eugenics effects on the far right tail of intelligence of the Chin

Originally published at 狗和留美者不得入内. You can comment here or there.

Over the past few months, I had read casually on the imperial examination system (科举) out of curiosity. My knowledge of it, the system that very much defined pre-modern Chinese society, is still very limited and vague, but now I at least know what 进士 and 秀才 are, along with some classical Chinese, background indispensable for understanding that system. I hope, if time permits, to learn more about this over the next year, on the side.

It has occurred to me that the imperial examination system, while doing much to prevent China from developing modern science as the West had for cultural reasons, did select for intelligence at the far tail. The reason is simple. The tests, which were very g-loaded, conferred those who scored highly on them wealth, position, and status that enabled them to have more children, and those from families who scored highly married those from similar families. Over time, there emerged an elite subpopulation with very high base genotypic IQ, one that results in those born from such families to regress not to the overall Chinese mean but to the high mean of that subpopulation. This is consistent with the fact that in the 20th century and probably even today, a disproportionately high percentage of top scholars, scientists, engineers, and even revolutionaries and political leaders of Chinese descent can be traced back to those elite 科举 families, based on the many examples I have seen. I’ll not give specific examples for now; they can easily be found by anyone who reads Chinese.

I will conclude with a note that is likely to be very relevant. Brian Bi, about a year ago, made this following IQ map of China by province.


You can also view it here.

First of all, the data may not be very accurate; I’ll have to check on its source. But for now, let’s assume that it is. Then, what’s most noticeable is the high average of Zhejiang, consistent with the number of mathematical and scientific geniuses of Zhejiangnese ancestry relative to the number of those with ancestry of other provinces, adjusted for province population of course. Examples are numerous: Shiing-Shen ChernWu WenjunFeng KangYitang Zhang, etc for math. There is also, in another field, Qian Xuesen. Too many to name. Brian Bi and I have wondered the cause of this. It is plausible that the aforementioned effect was much more pronounced in Zhejiang than in other provinces in China. Of course, there is a probably substantial environmental effect here too. So I guess to satisfy this curiosity, I might study some Zhejiangnese history as well.

Aside from prominence in science, Zhejiangnese are stereotyped in China for being really entrepreneurial. They are now one of the most prosperous provinces in China, needless to say. They are, to put it simply, a super breed among Chinese, to my superficial view.

Tags: heritability, psychometrics, 中国/китай, 浙江

  • 中国少数民族的语系分类

    汉藏语系 汉族:汉语族,12.2 亿 壮族:壮侗语族,1690 万,主要在广西 彝族:彝语支,870 万,主要在西南 土家族:840 万,主要在湖南,湖北,贵州 藏族:藏缅语族,630 万,主要在西藏 侗族 布衣族 白族 哈尼族 黎族 傣族…

  • 中国那帮英语培训机构基本都是垃圾,他们的创办人及工作者应当被处置

    刚跟朋友说了国庆放假,我在健身房,碰到了一个俄罗斯姑娘和个三十出头的中国女人一起。我跟她用俄语稍微聊了几句,也加了她和她的中国同事微信。然后,我得知她们是在培训班教小学生英语的。俄罗斯姑娘跟我说她在俄罗斯的 Перм 上大学,专业是德语,现在在中国已经待了一年了。…

  • 拼音英语字符比对服务

    我和朋友做了一个汉字转拼音的服务。什么给了我这个启发?是他有一次想让我在微信上用英语,可是我不想,因为觉得中文更快。然后自己做了个 小试验。 >>>…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened